Landslide Risk

 

Gutting the forest will greatly increase the risk of landslides.

There’s a detailed article here, with maps showing specific landslide risks on South Ridge and Edgewood.

Here’s a link to a news story “An Eerie Slide in SF,” about an actual slide that took down a house, fortunately unoccupied.

The eucalyptus and blackberry stabilize the hillside. UCSF’s claim that the South Ridge is not steep is not true, as anyone can verify by looking at the “Terrain” option in Google maps. The map below, excerpted from one prepared by State Geologists based on the US Geological Survey shows Mt Sutro as a hazard area for landslides.

landsliderisk

Landslide under blue tarp. South Ridge at top left.

Landslide under blue tarp. South Ridge at top left.

We have seen the effects of hillside erosion in the Forest Knolls neighborhood after trees on the hillsides were removed. On a slope on Warren Drive – directly downhill from South Ridge – a blue tarp the size of three houses covered the hillside for a long time before it was stable enough to remove.

Quite apart from actual major landslides, we can expect continual ongoing erosion and rockfalls as are apparent at Twin Peaks, which has similar terrain but no trees.

erosion twin peaks

These landslides could occur up to 6-8 years after the actual cutting, as the roots die and decay and stop binding the soil. An insurance professional pointed out that many insurance policies would not even cover damage to homes caused by such landslides; they would be excluded. (If your home is vulnerable, check the fine print on your policy or ask your agent.)

6 Responses to Landslide Risk

  1. Pingback: Puzzled #6 – UCSF: Landslides « Save Mount Sutro Forest

  2. Pingback: Help Save Mount Sutro Trails « Save Mount Sutro Forest

  3. Pingback: Tree Lovers vs Nativists: Matt Smith in the SF Weekly | Save Mount Sutro Forest

  4. Brian says:

    if done properly with a good game plan that included stabalizing the dirt by planting native bunch grasses shortly after removing the trees erosion could be controled and habitat restored. a WIN-WIN situation.

    • webmaster says:

      It’s not dirt. It’s rock. Have you seen the landslides on Twin Peaks? There are some after every heavy rain. On Twin Peaks, it doesn’t matter so much because it lands on the road and gets cleared up. In Mount Sutro, it would land on buildings and cars. There’s no way that bunch-grass could have the same stabilizing effect as an intergrafted mat of tree-roots a century old. See this post: https://sutroforest.com/2010/10/08/a-networked-forest/

  5. Pingback: Progress! UCSF’s Changed Plans for Mt Sutro Forest (Meeting Report) | Save Mount Sutro Forest

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s